NewsLocal NewsIn Your NeighborhoodPayette

Actions

New judge to be assigned to Stacey Wondra case, new court documents outline

Stacey Wondra Court 2026.jpg
Posted

PAYETTE, Idaho — A motion by Stacey Wondra and his counsel to assign a new judge to his case has been approved, according to new court documents.

As Idaho News 6 previously reported, Wondra was charged with kidnapping and murdering missing Fruitland boy Michael "Monkey" Vaughan.

On Wednesday, March 11, Wondra and his counsel motioned to disqualify the judge presiding on the case, Judge Gabriel McCarthy.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE | Stacey Wondra to stand trial for the murder of Michael 'Monkey' Vaughan

That motion was approved on March 12 and signed into certification by the Payette County Prosecutor's Office and the State Public Defender.

WATCH: Stacy Wondra appears in Payette County Court

New details revealed in Michael Vaughan case as murder suspect appears in court

The document outlined that the Administrative District Court Judge from the Third Judicial District will assign a different judge to Wondra's case.

According to Idaho Criminal Rule 25(a)(1), which deals with the disqualification of a judge, it says, "In any felony or misdemeanor criminal action, any party may disqualify one judge by filing a motion for disqualification without stating any grounds, and the motion must be granted if timely filed."

READ THE FULL DOCUMENT HERE—

ALSO READ | Mother of missing Fruitland boy stares down accused killer in Payette County courtroom